Determining which U.S. Virgin Island experience will offer you the most luxurious and memorable Caribbean vacation will soon lead you to a toss-up between St. Thomas and St. John. With pristine beaches, crystal-clear waters, and breathtaking natural beauty, both islands have the potential to offer you an unforgettable getaway.

The key to deciding which U.S. Virgin Island best suits you lies in what you're searching for in your vacation experience.

Those looking for a quieter and secluded escape may prefer the hidden Hull Bay beachfront found only in St. Thomas…making this destination our superior choice.

Kid-friendly poolside, at The Hideaway, St. Thomas

ACCESSIBILITY and INFRASTRUCTURE

St. Thomas, considered the gateway to the U.S. Virgin Islands, welcomes numerous flights from major cities into Cyril E. King International Airport, making it easier for luxury travelers to reach their destination with convenience and minimal hassle.

This accessibility to the island makes it incredibly convenient for travelers seeking a hassle-free journey to their dream vacation spot. On the other hand, St. John requires a ferry ride from St. Thomas, which, although picturesque, can add extra travel time and logistical complexities.

EXCLUSIVE ACCOMMODATIONS

Because St. John is a smaller island than St. Thomas, there aren't as many resorts around as you might expect.

St. Thomas is home to some hidden gems like The Hideaway at Hull Bay, offering various accommodation options that cater to the discerning luxury traveler.

“I loved this place. We had a 2 room cottage and felt like we had the place to ourselves. Lush foliage everywhere.” - Audra M.

From elegant waterfront villas to lavish beachfront resorts, The Hideaway at Hull Bay is a unique place in paradise for you to immerse yourself in the lap of luxury and experience personalized services, a private pool, stunning ocean views, and indulgent amenities. You and your guests may select to host a private event or corporate retreat offsite and enjoy the entire estate property to yourselves.

VIBRANT DINING and NIGHTLIFE

Considered the best of the US Virgin Islands for a reason, St. Thomas excels in offering an eclectic dining scene that satisfies even the most sophisticated palates.

The one-of-a-kind culinary experience at The Hideaway at Hull Bay indulges all of your senses with a custom dining experience — from dinner on the farm to a multicourse dinner under ambiance lighting in the open-air pavilion. Indulge in elevated dining, exclusively by reservation. Guests are guaranteed an uncrowded and opulent experience.

The island is home to an abundance of gourmet restaurants helmed by renowned chefs, where visitors can savor delectable international cuisine while enjoying breathtaking views of the Caribbean Sea.

While there are some cool spots on the Coral Bay (or eastern) side of St. John, many of them close around eight or nine o’clock. St. Thomas boasts chic bars, upscale lounges, and lively nightlife, ensuring endless entertainment opportunities for luxury travelers seeking excitement after the sun sets.

Visitors also select St. Thomas over St. John because of the post-beach farm-to-table dining experiences like the one offered at The Hideaway at Hull Bay or The Shack

WORLD-CLASS SHOPPING

As the more developed of the two islands, St. Thomas provides the thrill of high-end duty-free shopping, allowing visitors to indulge in luxury brands and designer goods. From upscale jewelry boutiques to fine art, St. Thomas is a shopper's paradise with its extensive range of options catering to luxury travelers' discerning tastes.

Travelers to St. Thomas find the best of both the modern world and the stillness of breathtaking natural surroundings. Guests staying at The Hideaway at Hull Bay should expect to experience serene stays, relaxing moments away from noisy crowds, and once-in-a-lifetime adventures off the beaten path.

EXCITING WATER ACTIVITIES

The Caribbean and St. Thomas specifically, presents many recreational activities and attractions for luxury travelers seeking adventure and exploration.

St. Thomas is renowned for its pristine beaches and crystal-clear waters, providing the perfect playground for water enthusiasts. Discover vibrant coral reefs, encounter exotic marine life and deep-sea fishing, or simply bask in the sun while paddleboarding or while on a yacht excursion.

Historical sites like Blackbeard's Castle and the 99 Steps also offer a glimpse of the island's intriguing, historical past.

A peek into one of the Cottages at The Hideaway.

THE BEST CHOICE

While both St. Thomas and St. John possess their own allure, St. Thomas’ private estate, The Hideaway at Hull Bay stands out as the ultimate luxury vacation destination.

Its accessibility, private accommodations, vibrant culture, elegant culinary delights, and exciting activities beyond noisy crowds make it a superior choice for those seeking an extravagant escape.

St. Thomas seamlessly blends opulence with natural beauty, promising a truly unforgettable experience for discerning travelers who want to enjoy the island on their terms.